A Quote about the CCO Council from Rudy Vidal
Join Your Peers and Share Your Insight. Become a Member
Already a member? Click here to sign in

CCO Council Blog

Home   »   CCO Council Blog

Losing the Trail

Friday, May 2010 at 7:54 PM
The mountain trail I had been climbing suddenly ended. I looked hard at every tree, turning in a slow circle, hoping to see the familiar yellow blaze on a tree that would mark the way forward.  As I started to cool down, the perspiration on my shirt began to freeze, and I felt the cold start eating at my exposed fingers and ears.  I had lost the trail.  

I was hiking in the White Mountains and had been following a well-traveled trail, clearly marked with yellow blazes on trees.  As I went further into the backcountry, I noticed more trees bearing the blazes had fallen down during the severe winter ice storms.  I wasn’t concerned because I could typically make out other signs of travel, such as a worn path, crushed leaves, or cut branches marking the trail others had traveled before.
 
Now I was lost, and the only hope I had was to retrace my steps, looking over my shoulder every few feet in hopes of returning to familiar territory.  I was racing against time and the cold.  After a time, I recognized the familiar yellow blaze on a tree.  Relief flooded through me.  I peered off into the distance and saw far away the next yellow blaze in a much different direction than I had taken previously.  Clearly, many other people had missed this marker and had mistakenly gone down the same wrong path. 

I was lucky.  I had followed in the footsteps of others who’d been equally lost, and I’d been able to return to familiar territory and once again find the correct path forward.  

How many of you are trying to navigate the poorly marked path towards customer loyalty, and find yourselves unsure where the next trail marker is, or worse, following what appears to be a well-trod path that leads you further and further away from you desired objective?  What are the consequences to your customers, your company, and you personally when you have to backtrack and reset, having experimented at customers’ expense and finding that you’ve lost the trail?

Are you merely a fire fighter, running from one customer crisis to another?  Or do you have a clear-cut strategy in place to prevent them from arising in the first place? Do you know what needs to happen after you’ve developed a comprehensive survey program?  Or how about if you find yourself in a customer crisis?  Do you have a response plan in place?  Do you know the critical steps to creating a stellar customer experience? 

Many executives have been able to reach their positions by “figuring things out” yet, at the C-Level, there simply isn’t room for this approach, and the consequences of taking the wrong path can be severe.  

As a CCO or customer executive, you need to find a way to abstract yourself from the inevitable day-to-day crises, and develop your long-term strategy.  This strategy needs to be grounded in reality and proven best practices.  

Such a comprehensive plan prevents you from wandering, and helps ensure you are focused on the right activities.  It proves to your CEO and your board that you are competent and deserve to be entrusted with the company’s most valuable assets: the customers. 

The members of the Chief Customer Officer Council have created the Chief Customer Officer Roadmap, which, like the yellow blazes on the trees, clearly marks the path you need to follow in your path towards creating a strong customer focus and engendering intensely loyal customers. It contains nearly 100 critical activities that you as the CCO or Customer Executive don’t necessarily need to own, but that you do need to ensure are implemented and sustained within your companies.  

The Chief Customer Officer Roadmap is broken down into a number of categories, and there is a loose, top-to-bottom and left-to-right progression.  The Roadmap also provides a rough priority order of activities in each section.  


More details on the CCO Roadmap are found on the CCO Council website

The CCO Roadmap enables you to focus on the most important activities first, and over time, broaden your horizons to better serve customers and deliver stronger corporate results, while saving you time because you don’t have to experiment at customers’ expense as you follow trails that lead nowhere and cost you precious time as you backtrack to familiar territory.  

If you haven’t already, please join us on the CCO Council so you can benefit from the invaluable experience of those who have blazed a clear trail for you to follow.  


February CCO Council Meeting Agenda

Wednesday, February 2010 at 9:10 PM

Folks,

We’ve just completed the February Chief Customer Officer (CCO) Council™ agenda, and it looks great!

The theme is “Igniting the Flame of Customer Centricity.” How do we ignite the spark around customer centricity and motivate organizations to act in our customer’s best interest? This effort to create a customer-centric culture is one of the most important of CCO goals, second only to driving more profitable customer behavior, and a strong factor in being able to deliver against the first goal. During our first Summit meeting last year, this issue was perhaps of the greatest interest but unfortunately it received the least attention.

Motivation is not simple; it must occur at multiple levels. To be successful, you may need to motivate your CEO and your Board. What role should you be playing in driving strategic alignment from the top down? You also need to effectively motivate your peers on the executive committee. One CCO told me how he creatively turned his greatest detractor, the CIO, into his staunchest ally overnight as he found the key to motivation that made the greatest difference. How can you create a shared sense of purpose rather than fighting turf wars at customers’ expense? Finally and most importantly, you need to motivate employees so they take pride in their work and delight in serving customers. How can you help each employee take ownership of customer loyalty, regardless of their role?

During this series of workshops and discussions, you will hear from renowned experts from Bates Communications, advisors to CEOs of Fortune-ranked companies such as Dow Chemical (#38), VF Outdoor (#335), Fidelity, and numerous others. In addition, you’ll learn what has worked for Jeb Dasteel, CCO of Oracle and recipient of the 2009 CCO of the Year award. Bob Olson will share his successes at GoDaddy & Homestead (an Intuit company) in turning tired, lackluster employees who could care less about customers into raving customer advocates, willing to do nearly anything for their customers.

During this intense meeting, members will have the opportunity to share success stories and most importantly, learn potential solutions to your immediate issues. As an attending member, you’ll walk away with a collection of new ideas, proven strategies, and a handful of best practices that will help ensure your success and increase your value to your organization, your CEO, and your customers.

I’ve appended below some of the highlights:

Creating the Customer Culture at Oracle (Jeb Dasteel, Oracle)

Jeb will share how he has been successful in motivating Oracle at all levels, and particularly how he has begun to use Oracle’s aggressive culture against itself to help everyone compete to become more customer-centric. Jeb will tell us how he’s managed to get his peers on board to eliminate turf wars or protective custody battles over customer ownership. Especially valuable, Jeb will tell us how he has created an environment where it is ok to experiment and fail, enabling significant customer breakthroughs.

Points for discussion:

  • Who provides your greatest obstacles to acting in your customers’ best interest?
  • What is the impact of their resistance on the organization and your customers
  • Is there one cultural theme that you could use to motivate people to change?
  • What happens to your customers if your employees are afraid to fail?
  • How do you make it safe for people to experiment?

The Modern Day Pied Piper: Getting People to Fall In Line Behind Customers (Bob Olson, MobileMini)

How can you get employees excited about your customers? How can you create a vision so compelling that they’re willing to do nearly anything for customers, including even taking a cut in pay? The modern day “Pied Piper,” Bob Olson is a veteran of numerous strongly customer-centric companies such as GoDaddy, Homestead Technologies (purchased by Intuit), and a recent work in progress, MobileMini. Bob describes how he’s created customer-centric cultures from the top down and from the ground up. He’ll share with us how he’s managed to co-create the vision with the CEO and his C-level peers, and especially how he’s motivated new and existing employees to shine forth. Bob will share some of the most impressive results he’s achieved in these companies, particularly in terms of profits generated as a result of such a strong employee focus.

Points for discussion:

  • How do your employees define their jobs? By their tasks and responsibilities? Output?
  • What matters most to your employees? A paycheck? Recognition?
  • How do you know if you have the right employees to achieve your vision? How have you connected employees to customers and vice versa?

Special CCO Program Development (Disney Institute)

For over 20 years, Disney Institute has offered over a million alumni the opportunity to benchmark the philosophies of The Walt Disney Company. As a special bonus, the CCO Council & the Disney Institute are co-developing a program uniquely tailored to your needs as a CCO that will be delivered at the Fall CCO Summit. This program will help you not only create a spectacular customer experience, but also develop and lead a phenomenal customer-centric culture. During this session you’ll learn of the programs, approaches, skills, and practices that have helped make Disney an international standard in motivating employees to deliver an exceptional customer experience. You’ll work with a Disney representative and your peers to develop an in-depth course that exactly meets your needs.

Igniting the Spark: Practical Tools to Creating a Firestorm of Customer Centricity (Craig Bentley, Bates Communications)

In your role as CCO, you need to ignite the spark of customer centricity, fan the flames of a customer-centric culture. How do you get the organization’s attention? How do you get everyone onboard? How do you keep them energized and focused—at all levels?

To do this successfully, you must be able to persuade, influence, and motivate all levels within the organization, from corporate leadership to the back office, and through to the front-line. In this interactive session, Craig Bentley of Bates Communications will introduce a few simple tools and techniques that will help you:

  • Discover that spark that gives the organization purpose around customers
  • Learn tools to accelerate the spark by connecting with your senior management peers and others in the organization
  • Be certain that your most important messages are being heard

Fan the flames by motivating your most important audiences to get the commitment and resources that you need to be successful

Overcoming Your Greatest Challenges (Peer to Peer Roundtable)

What is keeping you from being as successful as you desire? What would you most like to change about your role, your organization, your company, or even your customers? Come prepared to share the details of one or two critical issues and learn from your peers who’ve “been there, done that” and can tell you from experience exactly how they overcame similar problems—and the pitfalls to avoid. Brainstorm unique and innovative solutions with your peers that will help you turn these challenges into your next opportunity.

Points for discussion:

  • What (or whom) is hampering your efforts to drive results for your customers?
  • What strategy have you been wishing you could get input on?
  • What frustrates you the most—that you don’t feel like you can share with your peers?
  • If you could change one thing about your job, responsibilities, accountabilities, etc., what would it be?

Tags:

Categories: CCO Council

Look what’s coming for the CCO Council!

Wednesday, February 2010 at 9:00 PM

The Chief Customer Officer Council is gaining huge momentum with the recently completed CCO Roadmap, potential partnerships with Disney Institute and Gallup, and a number of new members.

Within about 2 weeks we’re launching an entirely new website with public and members-only forums that will provide a lot of CCO-specific and Council-generated content that will help you as a CCO be more successful in your role

Here’s a quick update on the things that are happening:

CCO Council Snapshot:

  • Membership is growing! We’ll be joined at our February meeting by Bob Olson, former CCO of Homestead Technologies (an Intuit Company) and GoDaddy, in addition to Jeff Lowe, the CCO of Telus (Canada’s largest telecom company).
  • We’re arranging a partnership with the Disney Institute to create a customized curriculum expressly for CCOs that teaches you not only how to create a spectacular customer experience, but also how to develop and lead a phenomenal customer-centric culture. This will be a major component of the 2010 CCO Summit, to be held in October.
  • We’re exploring a potential partnership with Gallup around the notion of Human Sigma, helping you achieve the appropriate balance of customer and employee focus as part of your overall strategy.
  • We’re booking a special engagement in April with Amir Hartman of Mainstay Partners, who will share the results of Oracle’s commissioned study of benchmark customer reference programs from around the world. Jeb Dasteel, CCO of Oracle, engaged Amir last year to perform a similar study and Amir has graciously agreed to share his updated results with the Council.
  • We’ve just completed the CCO Roadmap that details nearly 100 activities that you as a CCO need to ensure are implemented in your organization to ensure success. This roadmap is being expanded every month with best practices from the greatest experts on each topic in the roadmap.
  • We’re engaging in another major research project that aims to make explicit the connection between employee engagement and customer engagement, so you can decide how best to invest precious resources in your employees and know that it’ll have the greatest impact on loyalty. We’ve had some great input from Gallup around their Human Sigma model, incorporating their CE11 and Q12 metrics.

The Chief Customer Officer (CCO) Council™ helps you learn from your peers so you can drive customer centric business results–without experimenting at your customers’ expense.

The Council focuses on helping you succeed in three major areas:

  • Drive profitable customer behavior (ie. customer loyalty
  • Create customer-centric culture
  • Deliver solid business results that prove your value to the CEO, Board, and your peers

If you’re interested in learning more about the CCO Council and how it can help you succeed in your role, please feel free to contact me at 978-226-8675.

Curtis

Tags:

Categories:

Keynote Presentation: NACCM Customers 1st Conference, Nov 2009

Wednesday, February 2010 at 8:56 PM

Curtis Bingham and three Chief Customer Officer Council members were Keynote presenters at NACCM 2009: Customers 1st Conference, sponsored by Institute for International Research. The presentation was called: “The Ultimate in Customer Centricity: Chief Customer Officers Describe How Everyone Can Be A Loyalty Leader”

The CCO Council Panelists were: Tammy McLeod, Chief Customer Officer, Arizona Public Service; Bob Olson, Chief Customer Officer, Homestead Technologies, an Intuit Company; and Rudy Vidal, former Chief Customer Officer, InContact.

At the end of the session, the audience was asked to list their most valuable ‘take-aways’ from the session. Here are the top answers:

Top take-away strategies from Keynote session:

  • Support local establishments
  • Find unlikely allies
  • Have dissatisfied customers talk to management
  • Understand what emotions I want to drive, rather than what process to follow
  • You cannot separate employee engagement and customer loyalty
  • Make it everyone’s job

Below are media files of the session; to read a text transcript of the session, visit the Customer 1st blog linked below.

Audio only: NACCM Keynote Presentation Audio File (MP4)

Link to conference Homepage: http://www.iirusa.com/naccm/event-home.xml

Tags:

Categories:

Oracle’s Jeb Dasteel Awarded 2009 Chief Customer Officer of the Year

Wednesday, February 2010 at 8:49 PM

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

Oracle’s Jeb Dasteel Awarded
2009 Chief Customer Officer of the Year Award

Announcing the formation of the Chief Customer Officer Council

LITTLETON, MASS., July 8, 2009 – Customer loyalty is the Holy Grail for many businesses, yet in most organizations, nobody is accountable for loyalty improvement in the executive suite.

“The key to business success, particularly in a down economy, is anticipating customer needs and continuously deepening customer relationships,” according to Jeb Dasteel, Chief Customer Officer (CCO) of Oracle, who was named the 2009 Chief Customer Officer of the Year last month at the first ever Chief Customer Officer Summit.

“Through a string of 55 acquisitions, Oracle has achieved nearly 100% customer retention,” Dasteel said. “We’ve gotten really good at listening to customers, prioritizing feedback, and driving customer strategy at all levels. The award is a great honor and a testament to Oracle’s executive leadership that has provided such visible support for the customer focus we’ve tried to achieve.”

Dasteel has been with Oracle for 11 years, five of which have been spent running Oracle’s Global Customer Programs and as CCO for the last year.

“Several years ago it became clear to us that the Chief Customer Officer role was a missing piece of Oracle’s strategy. Our CCO has become a key part of the Oracle transformation. The pay-off has been tremendous as we become more of a trusted partner to our customers,” said Charles Phillips, President of Oracle.

“Jeb Dasteel has made exceptional strides in improving customer relationships, driving profitable customer behavior, and in creating customer-centric cultures,” noted Curtis N. Bingham, founder of the Chief Customer Officer Council that awarded Dasteel. “Unless you’re Disney where the customer is injected into the cultural DNA, you need someone to champion the customer cause. Otherwise, opportunities are squandered, customers leave, and innovation is squelched.”

Most companies have neither the process nor the executive-level accountability to devise and execute customer strategy in order to increase loyalty and attendant profits. “In fact, less than 25 of the Fortune 1000 companies have a Chief Customer Officer,” said Bingham. “CCOs are the ultimate authority on customers and drive customer and corporate strategy at the highest levels of the company.” The three greatest responsibilities of a CCO are: 1.) Creating customer strategy based on in-depth customer insight, 2.) Driving profitable customer behavior, and 3.) Creating a customer-centric culture. CCOs are typically hired to resolve chronic customer crises, protect revenue derived from an organization’s current customer base, and establish competitive advantage.

Announcing the CCO Council

In June 2009, the 16 CCOs gathered at the Chief Customer Officer Summit agreed:

  • Increased transparency in product roadmaps, service agreements, and pricing is driving increased loyalty and stronger customer retention as well as acquisition
  • Improved customer intimacy, particularly during down economic times, is an extremely potent competitive barrier
  • In the current economy, CCOs are finding they must enable customer-facing functions to have different value discussions with customers and prospects. Decisions are being made at a higher level, requiring additional executive-level insight. Customers are trading downwards, requiring stronger value propositions than before.
  • The Customer Experience is made up of multiple touchpoints, and the greatest ROI can be obtained by identifying those touchpoints with the greatest emotional attachment for customers and resolving issues there first.

The CCOs all saw huge value in collaborating with their peers via the newly formed Chief Customer Officer Council to improve customer relationships and advance their careers. Bingham founded the Chief Customer Officer Council based on the needs of more than 50 Chief Customer Officers with whom he has worked since starting in the field in 2003. Curtis is the author of the forthcoming book entitled The Key to Customer Strategy: The Rise of the Chief Customer Officer to be published by HRD Press in late 2009.

The CCO Council is dedicated to elevating the role of the CCO in establishing business strategy, helping its members grow professionally, and most importantly, helping drive solid, customer-focused results in member organizations. Each year the Council recognizes with an award the CCO that has made the greatest strides on improving customer relationships, driving profitable customer behavior, and in creating customer-centric cultures. As well, the Council recognizes the CCO that has had the greatest impact on his or her peers in helping others achieve similar results.

Curtis N. Bingham is President of Predictive Consulting Group, a firm that helps companies increase customer acquisition, retention, and customer profitability through customer strategy. He is also the founder of the Chief Customer Officer Council.

Contact:Curtis N. Bingham
(978) 952-0047
Predictive Consulting Group, Inc
Founder, Chief Customer Officer Council
curtis@ccocouncil.org

Chrysler’s Customer Experience Efforts Backfire

Wednesday, February 2010 at 8:42 PM

Sometimes the brilliant efforts to gather customer insight simply backfire.  Consider for a moment the experience of buying a car.  Your feedback can make or break the dealership’s performance rating, and it is so important that many dealerships have resorted to cheesy gimmicks like, “If you had a perfect experience today, please fill out a form.”

Chrysler is clearly taking it further and bypassing some of this chicanery to get to the heart of the matter.  Yet they blew it, and may have ruined the overall experience with one mistake.

A colleague forwarded this to me:

Dear Mr. ZZZ:
Congratulations and thank you for buying your 2009 Jeep Grand Cherokee from Dealership Inc. Jeep and Dealership Inc appreciate your purchase.

It is important that we provide you with the best possible ownership experience. To help us do so, we invite you to complete our brief survey regarding your recent purchase experience. Your feedback is a valuable tool to help improve the experiences of our customers as well as guide future product development efforts. Your participation in the survey process is completely voluntary.

Please complete the survey at https://survey.cdjcustomersat.com. If you are prompted for a password, please enter the following: ZZZ

Thanks again,
Douglas D. Betts
Vice President & Chief Customer Officer
Chrysler Motors

My colleague was interested in sharing a decent experience–nothing stellar, but nothing bad either.   However, when he went to fill out the survey, he received the error message that the survey had expired, a mere 10 days after the receipt of the survey email.

I thought it was admirable that Douglas signed his name. However, his name has been besmirched.  The customer decided that Chrysler really didn’t have its act together.  And Chrysler spoiled a potential loyalty-building opportunity.

Don’t let simple mistakes ruin great opportunities to build loyalty, because when you reach out like this and blow it, you cause more damage than if you’d never said a thing.

Tags:

Categories:

Highlights of the 2009 CCO Study

Wednesday, February 2010 at 8:35 PM

Nearly 6 years ago when I first began to study the relatively unknown role of Chief Customer Officer (CCO), I found fewer than 20 in the world and I spent time with half of them, including Marissa Peterson of Sun Microsystems, Doug Allred of Cisco, and Jeff Lewis of Monster.com. The insights these luminaries shared were incredible, and were included in the Predictive Consulting Group Executive-Level Customer Champions Report I published through 2006.

Fast-forward to today: there are now over 200 officially-titled Chief Customer Officers in the world, and hundreds more with similar titles, and I’ve worked with or interviewed nearly 30% of them. The role is evolving dramatically and spectacularly, with some particularly impressive results. Companies as large as Oracle, Cisco, SAP have Chief Customer Officers as do many mid- and small-cap companies. For these companies, the CCO role is crucial to establishing and executing an effective customer strategy. CEOs of companies large and small are recognizing that customers are truly their most valuable asset and are exploring the possibility of appointing a Chief Customer Officer to help nurture and grow this asset.

Here are some of the fascinating highlights from CCOs around the world:

  • The CCO role is growing in popularity at an increasing rate, particularly in the mid-cap market. It is surprising to see how many CCOs there are in the industry today.
  • CCOs are becoming more generalized: The demarcation between the three types of CCOs that I identified in my 2005 Business Strategy article (http://predictiveconsulting.com/articles/HBS-2005-Hottest-New-Title2.html) is blurring. Many CCOs are no longer focusing solely on customer satisfaction and retention, and are beginning to focus on leveraging customer insight to drive the customer acquisition activities as well.

While the reasons are varied, CEOs hire a CCO for one of three primary reasons:

  • Address unresolved customer crises: They are experiencing unresolved customer crises that they have not been successful in fixing on their own, such as extremely dissatisfied customers due to chronic product issues, customer lawsuits arising from unmet expectations, etc. larger companies tend to fall in this group.
  • Create Competitive Advantage: In small- and mid-cap companies, CEOs recognize that they need to differentiate themselves from their (sometimes larger) competitors and appoint a CCO to prove to their customers and prospects that they are singularly committed to customer success. Many a deal has been inked after a visit from the Chief Customer Officer.
  • Retain existing customers: Customers were defecting, revenues were plummeting. The Chief Customer Officer was able to provide operational stability by focusing on retaining customers to protect revenue.
  • Big differences between CCOs in small vs. larger companies: CCOs in small- to mid-cap companies typically have line ownership of customer-facing functions including marketing, sales, support, and professional services, whereas those in larger companies have vast matrix authority and limited line ownership.
  • Interestingly, numerous CCOs were hired by a newly-appointed CEO that had come from a highly customer-centric company. These CEOs wanted a partner to change culture and help them reach their growth goals.
  • An increasing number of CCOs have a sales or technology background: When I first began this research I was adamant that someone from sales or IT had no place in the CCO role. I’m pleased to find that I’ve been proven wrong! There are a number of CCOs that have come up through the sales organizations and are being very successful. Charlie Isaacs of Kana is also the company’s CTO and is unique in his ability to advocate for the customer with his in-depth understanding of their technology needs.
  • There is a proliferation of Executive Advisory Councils and Customer Advisory boards: Some companies have numerous executive councils and hundreds of customer advisory boards. The challenge for some companies remains in ensuring that the advisory boards are more than focus groups and provide significant input to the overall strategy.
  • One finding that surprised me was the number of public utilities that have a CCO, including PG&E, Arizona Public Service, 407ETR in Canada, and others. In a later blog article I’ll talk about the reasons why a near-monopoly would want to embark on such a journey.
  • The vast majority of CCOs are tied in some fashion to either the creation or preservation of revenue. When I first started the research six years ago, many CCOs were embroiled in a battle with their Utopia and reality. They quickly realized that focusing on the customers simply because it is the right thing to do cannot survive an economic downturn. Thankfully, most of the CCOs I’ve worked with recently are tied to revenue and therefore more immune to cuts than before.
  • A number of similar titles are cropping up that aren’t truly meaningful, like Chief Experience Officer, Customer Satisfaction Officer. These job functions are subsets of the Chief Customer Officer and focus too much attention on customer satisfaction/retention and not enough on the overall customer strategy.

There are many, many more insights yet to come, so stay tuned for future updates!

Tags:

Categories:

Can loyalty be created only through 'surprisingly' good experiences?

Wednesday, February 2010 at 8:33 PM

I had just entered an airport after turning in my rental car when I heard someone running up behind me, shouting “Mr. Bingham! Wait!”  I turned around, wondering what could possibly be so important that someone was running and calling my name.  The Avis agent, clearly out of breath, handed me my cell phone that I had mistakenly left plugged into the car.   I thanked him profusely–this could’ve been a huge disaster, with all my contacts, calendar, and email missing I’d have been in deep trouble.  I tried to tip him for his efforts, but he refused.

So many people believe that loyalty can only be created by “surprise.”  In other words, loyalty is engendered through a constantly escalating series of unexpected “above-and-beyond” experiences.  This notion is erroneous and hugely dangerous.  Customers don’t need to be “surprised” at every turn, and trying to do so rapidly creates an unreachable and unprofitable standard.

I was “surprised” by this Avis agent going above and beyond the minimum required of him, but in truth, he was not trying to surprise me, he was instead treating me like I would want to be treated.  Despite being a perfect stranger, he treated me like a best friend would, knowing how important my cell phone is to me as a lifeline to my customers, my business, and my family.  Avis did a fantastic job of treating me the way that I want to be treated. National Car Rental did similarly well until they sent me a follow-up notice that I talked about on my customer strategy blog at curtisbingham.com.

Customers need to have their basic needs met in spades.  The product must function as advertised, it must be delivered, installed, and maintained as advertised.  These are the building blocks of satisfaction.  However, to engender loyalty, a company must know their customers well enough to understand and anticipate higher-order needs and desires. Companies must be able to treat increasingly smaller customer segments the way they want to be treated.  The surprise may come as a side-effect (“Gee, how did you know that I was struggling with this problem?”), but it shouldn’t be the primary goal and desired outcome.

Consumer-package goods companies used promotions and coupons to drive behavior and in so doing have trained their customers to only purchase if something is on sale. They’ve commoditized their own products.  In the same way, seeking solely to surprise is a sure way to commoditize your service.  You train people to raise their expectations and soon what was once surprising becomes commonplace.  It becomes more costly at every turn to address outrageous and unnecessary expectations in this game of one-upmanship.  No, you need to simply treat them the way they want to be treated–as though you were a best friend looking out for them.  Your customer strategy must involve understanding your customer segments’ needs at an increasingly granular level and meeting stated or anticipated needs.  Let the surprise come from sometimes knowing more about the customers than they know about themselves.

What do you think?  Can loyalty only be created through "surprise"?

Tags:

Categories:

Here’s a Quarter, Call Someone Who Cares

Wednesday, February 2010 at 8:28 PM

Some time ago there was a Country & Western song entitled, “Here’s a quarter, call someone who cares.” I don’t remember the lyrics or even who sang it, but this is the new catchphrase for United Airlines.

In last week’s Wall Street Journal it was announced that United is dropping an Indian customer-call center that took compliments or complaints, telling customers to write or email instead. All customer communications will now be devoid of any customer relations phone numbers.

United claims they’ve done the research and “people who email or write us are more satisfied with our responses.” Come on. That’s just plain stupid. It is either a blatantly bad cover-up for cost-reduction, or a gross misreading of customer data. So many companies I’ve spoken with recently are reversing their offshoring decisions. They’re finding that the overseas costs are soaring, the strong accents are off-putting for angry customers, and the results no longer justify the expense and hassle.

In this case, I’ve got to believe that United’s higher satisfaction scores are due to the fact that written English is far more easily understood than spoken as a second language.

There is a ton of research to prove that disgruntled customers want to speak with real humans, right now to gain resolution and closure. To force someone to write a letter only forces them to sit and stew on the issue. More research proves that they’ll tell anywhere from 2-30 other people about their bad experience. Is the cost cutting in this area truly worth it? This is a great example of what happens when you lose sight of your customer strategy and make decisions based on costs alone rather than on a detailed understanding and appreciation of long-term customer value.

United had a Chief Customer Officer, Graham Atkinson, but in October of last year, he was put out to pasture and Dennis Cary, the CMO took over the CCO role. I had a nightmare of a time trying to reach Mr. Atkinson for my book.  I was told repeatedly to email their support lines to request an interview only to be repeatedly ignored.

This bald-faced cost-cutting move sounds like what happens when nobody is truly accountable to the customer and even worse, when someone merely assumes a sexy title in an appearance of customer intimacy.  Dennis Cary, if you’re out there, please prove me wrong.

Tags:

Categories:

Customer Insight Is Too Good To Waste

Wednesday, February 2010 at 8:24 PM

I was reading a blog today about a company’s efforts to gather customer insight using a well-known research institution and it occurred to me that while gathering customer satisfaction scores is a good thing to do, many companies that I’ve worked with start their customer insight collection with massive surveys and end up wasting opportunities for strategic input to their overall customer strategy. In my experience at companies large and small as well as in interviews with scores of Chief Customer Officers (CCOs) for my upcoming book entitled, The Key to Customer Strategy:  The Rise of the Chief Customer Officer, I’ve found that there must needs be a sequence of customer insight collection methods from coarse to granular, and expensive to economical.  This approach may at first seem counterintuitive, but actually yields the most valuable results that drive profitable customer loyalty.

If you simply begin with satisfaction surveys as your primary view of the customer, you may well capture “dissatisfiers” or those things that are currently damaging customer relationships and must be fixed immediately. However, you miss the most valuable information, namely the real reason why your customers buy, what they value the most, whether they may be willing to pay more, and even more importantly, where your customers are going next and how you can lead them there.

To achieve this type of insight and more fully inform their customer strategy, the best companies have a hierarchy of customer insight collection methods:

1. Executive advisory council to understand strategic imperatives:  This mechanism gets senior-most executives (the economic buyers) from critical customers together to understand their highest-level business challenges and directions.  This input is critical in determining future directions your company must begin to consider because if your customers are heading in a direction that you aren’t, you’ll be left behind.

2. More tactical customer advisory boards:  Companies may have customer advisory boards for each major product line or customer segment they are in.  They are primarily comprised of product/service users and influencers.  Broadly speaking, these groups provide a wonderful focus group in which customers can speak their mind, share their issues and problems and get help from their colleagues and the company, as well as  react to forthcoming products/services and activities.

3. Direct interviews of key customers:  Direct interviews are incredibly important to truly understand customer value drivers:  ie. the critical reasons why your customers buy from you (see this blog post and this article published in CEO Refresher for more information on value drivers). Direct interviews are critical to uncover all the hidden issues, learn the context of problems, and even more importantly, discover new opportunities only exposed through direct, contextual interviews.  These direct interviews will refine questions and inform the large-scale customer surveys.

4. Large-scale customer surveys:  The surveys, by their very nature, need to be confirmatory–they need to validate the insights you’ve gained to date and confirm or otherwise assess the scope of the issues you are seeking insight into.   It is extremely hard to get strategic insight if you simply start with surveys unless you follow up with interviews, which simply indicates the need to have started with interviews beforehand.

5. Focused working interviews:  The large-scale surveys will invariable confirm issues that need to be addressed, and you’ll need to gather your cross-functional teams together to get to the root cause of the issue confirmed through the previous steps, propose solutions, and upon implementation, evaluate their success.

It may be tempting to simply send out a survey and call it good.  In my experience, surveys  can can be subject to many pitfalls that I’ve previously written about on my Customer Strategy Blog.  Squash this temptation.  Just like you don’t allow your sales people to go into a customer visit without preparing, you can’t allow your company to just send out a survey without fully informing the survey.

You only have so many silver bullets in your gun when it comes to your customers.  Do your homework first and make sure that when you spend your silver bullet and ask your customers to help you out, that you get only the insight you really need to drive your business forward.

Tags:

Categories: Customer Insight | Customer Survey